Guest Post by PlanetNL
PlanetNL24:
Time to Rezone the Island Grid
The matter of backup power needs on the Avalon, as analysed in
PlanetNL23, brings into focus a bigger issue about fairness to the many
off-Avalon ratepayers. Nalcor’s
Reliability and Resource Adequacy Study confirmed that Muskrat energy is to be
delivered specifically to the Avalon end of Island grid to meet Avalon power
needs. The future addition of new
Combustion Turbines (CTs) is also a response to
an Avalon-specific risk issue. The issue is not a new one – just an
ignored one.
The high cost Holyrood Thermal
Generating Station existed principally to satisfy Avalon winter power needs
while the off-Avalon portion of the Island Interconnected System (IIS) was
essentially self-sufficient on low cost hydro-power. Despite this inequality of need and inequality
of cost of power, all IIS ratepayers pay an equal rate. With Muskrat rate increases just around the
corner, it’s time to put this issue under the spotlight and propose a fairer
allocation of costs.
The Uncle Gnarley Blog has a new website. Click here to visit www.unclegnarley.ca to view the latest posts!
Monday, 8 April 2019
Thursday, 4 April 2019
ATLANTIC ACCORD: DEAL OF A CHARLATAN
One word describes
Premier Ball. That word is “charlatan”. Other synonyms offered by Wikipedia include
trickster, fraudster and hoaxer. All describe a person who is not forthright. Ball
is selling his “Atlantic Accord” deal as something to be proud of. It is
anything but.
On Monday, April 1st, the Premier announced in his own words “an agreement that ensures Newfoundlanders and Labradorians are the principal beneficiaries of their offshore resources, strengthens how those resources are developed through joint management, and will also achieve electricity rate mitigation.”
How “rate mitigation” for the Muskrat Falls project found its way into a deal about the Atlantic Accord, as former Premier Brian Peckford noted in his commentary, is baffling
On Monday, April 1st, the Premier announced in his own words “an agreement that ensures Newfoundlanders and Labradorians are the principal beneficiaries of their offshore resources, strengthens how those resources are developed through joint management, and will also achieve electricity rate mitigation.”
How “rate mitigation” for the Muskrat Falls project found its way into a deal about the Atlantic Accord, as former Premier Brian Peckford noted in his commentary, is baffling
Monday, 1 April 2019
NEW NL HYDRO CHIEF SHOULD START OVER
Denial
and deception came easily to the politicians and bureaucrats who had the
audacity to sanction Muskrat. Jennifer
Williams, the new NL Hydro President, should decide now if she will take a
different path than that taken by the recent Hydro Executives who helped enable
the project.
Hydro
management remained quiet as Hydro’s Board of Directors imposed a 50-year “take
or pay” contract on the province’s ratepayers — for the full capital cost of
Muskrat Falls. This contract flies in the face of Hydro’s obligations to
protect their customers and to supply power on an effective and efficient
basis. The Board shares in the blame for the
creation of an economic condition that threatens our economy and the
affordability of basic heat and light.
Thursday, 28 March 2019
BIRD FEEDERS AND THE ATLANTIC ACCORD
Guest Post by "Agent 13"
Bird
Feeders and The Atlantic Accord
(who's running this place anyway)
We have all heard the old joke about the Alien looking down at St. John’s and seeing humans picking up after their dogs, coming to the conclusion that the dogs must be in charge.
This got me wondering what the same Alien might conclude if they listened to our local News.
Could they identify our Leaders?
For starters, a totally stressed City Council have figured out the pressing issue is that “some” people in St. John’s have too many bird feeders. They want an immediate stop to the trend. The City plans a new by-law.
(who's running this place anyway)
We have all heard the old joke about the Alien looking down at St. John’s and seeing humans picking up after their dogs, coming to the conclusion that the dogs must be in charge.
This got me wondering what the same Alien might conclude if they listened to our local News.
Could they identify our Leaders?
For starters, a totally stressed City Council have figured out the pressing issue is that “some” people in St. John’s have too many bird feeders. They want an immediate stop to the trend. The City plans a new by-law.
Monday, 25 March 2019
MORE PRE-SANCTION FRAUD OR INCOMPETENCE?
Guest Post by PlanetNL
PlanetNL23:
Backup Power Risks Reveal More Pre-Sanction Shenanigans
Two new reports on the Public Utilities Board (PUB) website
shatter the illusion that the Muskrat Falls project will avoid the need for
oil-fired generation in the province. Upon
decommissioning of the 490MW steam generation capacity at the Holyrood Thermal
Generating Station, there is a critical reliability scenario arising in the all
too likely event the Labrador Island Link (LIL) experiences an outage that will
lead to a 500MW capacity deficit on the Avalon Peninsula. Another report identifies that even when
Muskrat runs optimally, there is insufficient capacity reserve without the
addition of two new 58.5MW Combustion Turbines (CTs).
This new information gives further evidence of how Nalcor
distorted the comparison of the Isolated vs Interconnected pre-sanction
scenarios to favour Muskrat. As reality
sets in, Nalcor finds itself left with only one viable solution: the installation
of several new diesel CTs, likely on the very same Holyrood site. The irony of building the colossal Muskrat
Falls megaproject for the purpose of closing Holyrood, only to find that a
direct replacement must be constructed, is an astonishingly shameful exposure
of Nalcor’s deceit.
Sunday, 24 March 2019
BARD'S QUESTION FOR THE AGING MASSES
WHEN FEEBLE COMES
A question for the aging masses:
When feeble comes,
Who’ll wipe our arses?
In this time of smartphone fret
And fixation on the internet,
If wiping can’t be done by app.
Thursday, 21 March 2019
FIFTEEN TAKEAWAYS PHASE I MUSKRAT FALLS INQUIRY
Guest
Post by Muskrat Falls Concerned Citizens Coalition Members David Vardy, Ron Penney and Des Sullivan
Now that the second phase of the Inquiry has begun it may be helpful to take stock of where we are and what we have learned to date.
Here are fifteen key issues on which the Inquiry Commissioner, Richard LeBlanc, must opine and about which the public should be informed. We have not attempted to assign priorities to them but we can say they that, while they are important, there are others issues that have been identified. We will post them another time.
1. When the Muskrat Falls project was sanctioned there was only a three per cent probability that the project would be completed on time, based on evidence provided by Nalcor’s risk consultant Richard Westney.
Now that the second phase of the Inquiry has begun it may be helpful to take stock of where we are and what we have learned to date.
Here are fifteen key issues on which the Inquiry Commissioner, Richard LeBlanc, must opine and about which the public should be informed. We have not attempted to assign priorities to them but we can say they that, while they are important, there are others issues that have been identified. We will post them another time.
1. When the Muskrat Falls project was sanctioned there was only a three per cent probability that the project would be completed on time, based on evidence provided by Nalcor’s risk consultant Richard Westney.
Monday, 18 March 2019
THE ATLANTIC ACCORD: BE AFRAID, BE VERY AFRAID
It is not a good feeling when government cannot be trusted.
Yet, notwithstanding all the partisan nonsense that props up one Party over another, it is the trust that government acts solely in the public interest that keeps the democratic system strong.
It is an issue that permeates many of the articles and comments that appear on this Blog. Underneath them is the fear, to phrase it in the vernacular, that the Ball Government will “sell the Province down the river”.
There is reason for that and, paradoxically as it may seem, the origins of such scepticism are found with Ball’s Tory predecessors.
Yet, notwithstanding all the partisan nonsense that props up one Party over another, it is the trust that government acts solely in the public interest that keeps the democratic system strong.
It is an issue that permeates many of the articles and comments that appear on this Blog. Underneath them is the fear, to phrase it in the vernacular, that the Ball Government will “sell the Province down the river”.
There is reason for that and, paradoxically as it may seem, the origins of such scepticism are found with Ball’s Tory predecessors.
Monday, 11 March 2019
BEWARE FEDERAL SHAPESHIFTING ON ATLANTIC ACCORD, WARNS CABOT MARTIN
Guest Post by Cabot Martin
Hooray for Uncle Gnarley for he has saved me from the sloth of procrastination!
Nearly a week had passed since former Premier Peckford’s letter appeared in the Saturday March 2nd edition of the St. John’s Telegram and I was still mulling over an appropriate way to support his views; maybe phone Paddy; maybe a letter to the Telegram.
So when Uncle Gnarley phoned last Thursday to ask me to write something on the Atlantic Accord mess, it didn’t take any convincing at all.
So to A. Brian’s excellent letter.
I was most struck by his comment on a possible change in the Accord that would see us being demoted from “principal beneficiary” to ”primary beneficiary” – a big change in a key, supposedly entrenched right.
Hooray for Uncle Gnarley for he has saved me from the sloth of procrastination!
Nearly a week had passed since former Premier Peckford’s letter appeared in the Saturday March 2nd edition of the St. John’s Telegram and I was still mulling over an appropriate way to support his views; maybe phone Paddy; maybe a letter to the Telegram.
So when Uncle Gnarley phoned last Thursday to ask me to write something on the Atlantic Accord mess, it didn’t take any convincing at all.
So to A. Brian’s excellent letter.
I was most struck by his comment on a possible change in the Accord that would see us being demoted from “principal beneficiary” to ”primary beneficiary” – a big change in a key, supposedly entrenched right.
Thursday, 7 March 2019
WERE SNC LAVALIN TROUBLES OPPORTUNISTIC FOR NALCOR?
Guest Post by David Vardy
SNC LAVALIN: THE MUSKRAT FALLS EXPERIENCE
SNC Lavalin’s role in the Muskrat Falls project has figured prominently in recent hearings of the Muskrat Falls Inquiry. On Friday the Inquiry heard from Nalcor’s senior procurement officer on the project’s management practices, including those which led to the selection of SNC Lavalin (SLI) as EPCM contractor in 2011 and to their removal from this role in 2013.
The New York Times had this to say on the biggest scandal facing Prime Minister Justin Trudeau:
“The case revolves around accusations that SNC-Lavalin, a multinational engineering company based in Quebec, paid 47.7 million Canadian dollars in bribes to officials in Libya to win contracts there, and defrauded the Libyan government and its agencies of 129.8 million Canadian dollars.
“The prime minister and his aides have been accused of pressuring his justice minister at the time, Jody Wilson-Raybould, to drop the criminal inquiry against the company because a conviction could potentially cost thousands of jobs in Canada, and diminish his Liberal Party’s political fortunes.”
SNC LAVALIN: THE MUSKRAT FALLS EXPERIENCE
SNC Lavalin’s role in the Muskrat Falls project has figured prominently in recent hearings of the Muskrat Falls Inquiry. On Friday the Inquiry heard from Nalcor’s senior procurement officer on the project’s management practices, including those which led to the selection of SNC Lavalin (SLI) as EPCM contractor in 2011 and to their removal from this role in 2013.
The New York Times had this to say on the biggest scandal facing Prime Minister Justin Trudeau:
“The case revolves around accusations that SNC-Lavalin, a multinational engineering company based in Quebec, paid 47.7 million Canadian dollars in bribes to officials in Libya to win contracts there, and defrauded the Libyan government and its agencies of 129.8 million Canadian dollars.
“The prime minister and his aides have been accused of pressuring his justice minister at the time, Jody Wilson-Raybould, to drop the criminal inquiry against the company because a conviction could potentially cost thousands of jobs in Canada, and diminish his Liberal Party’s political fortunes.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)