On
the Witness Stand at the Muskrat Falls Inquiry, former Premier Paul Davis displayed
the confidence of one who believed he knew what he was talking about. A
confident Derrick Dalley, the former Tory Minister of Natural Resources,
succeeded him. Trouble is, confidence is no substitute for the good judgment
they ought to have brought to their senior positions.
Expected
was leadership worldly-wise enough to understand the need for a process that
assured “oversight” of the project at the highest level. The decision required
personnel of international stature that was “earned” — not “awarded” by Kathy Dunderdale.
Little
wonder that Davis was once dubbed the “Corporal Premier” on this Blog, having admitted
to the Inquiry that his chief source of information on Muskrat was Dalley.
The Uncle Gnarley Blog has a new website. Click here to visit www.unclegnarley.ca to view the latest posts!
Monday, 4 March 2019
Thursday, 28 February 2019
WILL THE PUB GO FAR ENOUGH ON RATE MITIGATION?
Guest Post by David Vardy
The
PUB has been asked to make recommendations as to how increases in power rates
arising from Muskrat Falls can be avoided, a daunting task indeed, but one for
which they have been given a broad mandate.
They have just released an interim report on measures to increase
revenues and reduce costs. Their work plan is quite ambitious and covers a wide
range of options. The question is how far they will go and how receptive will
government be to major changes?
Will
they recommend the kind of surgery needed to right-size our electric power
industry and to extirpate Nalcor as an unregulated monopoly? Will they go so
far as to propose that Nalcor be removed from the power system after Muskrat
Falls has been completed?
Monday, 25 February 2019
LAW SCHOOL IGNORES PROVINCE'S FISCAL POSITION
Guest Post by Ron Penney
On March 14th the Board of Regents of Memorial University will have it’s regularly scheduled meeting and it is anticipated that the issue of creating a new Law School at Memorial will be discussed.
The academic governing body of the University, the Senate, has approved the creation of the Law School but the final decision will be made by the Board of Regents, who will hopefully demonstrate more sense than Senate.
It is amazing that the most highly educated body in the Province, the Senate, is totally oblivious to our fiscal situation, which the Parliamentary Budget Officer describes as the most dire in the country.
On March 14th the Board of Regents of Memorial University will have it’s regularly scheduled meeting and it is anticipated that the issue of creating a new Law School at Memorial will be discussed.
The academic governing body of the University, the Senate, has approved the creation of the Law School but the final decision will be made by the Board of Regents, who will hopefully demonstrate more sense than Senate.
It is amazing that the most highly educated body in the Province, the Senate, is totally oblivious to our fiscal situation, which the Parliamentary Budget Officer describes as the most dire in the country.
Thursday, 21 February 2019
WHO TAKES ED MARTIN SERIOUSLY, ANYWAY?
When journalists interview Ed Martin, as CBC’s Terry Roberts
did a few days ago, it is right to wonder if they go away laughing.
Unfortunately, the reporter’s interview with Martin is found only on the CBC website, so images of him uproariously slapping his sides can only be imagined.
Terry Robert’s story is about Ed Martin dissing Astaldi. Martin thinks that the Company is “largely to blame for the massive cost and schedule overruns” experienced on the Muskrat Falls project.
Unfortunately, the reporter’s interview with Martin is found only on the CBC website, so images of him uproariously slapping his sides can only be imagined.
Terry Robert’s story is about Ed Martin dissing Astaldi. Martin thinks that the Company is “largely to blame for the massive cost and schedule overruns” experienced on the Muskrat Falls project.
Monday, 18 February 2019
FORENSIC AUDIT: NALCOR IGNORED BIG EARLY WARNING SIGNS
The Uncle Gnarley Blog has posted two commentaries on the second Forensic Audit Report of Grant Thornton released today by the Commission of Inquiry into the Muskrat Falls Project. Both articles were prepared by Ron Penney, David Vardy and Des Sullivan who have standing at the Inquiry on behalf of the Concerned Citizens Coalition.
This piece contains the key findings of the Forensic Audit. Also posted is a lengthier and more thorough examination of the Report entitled “Evidence of Malfeasance?: A Review of the Forensic Audit Report into the Muskrat Falls Project (Phase II)”. It is available now at the Link. - Des Sullivan
HIGHLIGHTS OF SECOND FORENSIC AUDIT REPORT
As was the case with Phase One of the Muskrat Falls Inquiry, the construction phase of the Inquiry has commenced with the release today of the forensic audit conducted by Grant Thornton.
This piece contains the key findings of the Forensic Audit. Also posted is a lengthier and more thorough examination of the Report entitled “Evidence of Malfeasance?: A Review of the Forensic Audit Report into the Muskrat Falls Project (Phase II)”. It is available now at the Link. - Des Sullivan
HIGHLIGHTS OF SECOND FORENSIC AUDIT REPORT
As was the case with Phase One of the Muskrat Falls Inquiry, the construction phase of the Inquiry has commenced with the release today of the forensic audit conducted by Grant Thornton.
The
audit sets the stage for the examination of witnesses crucial to the
understanding of how the project went so badly wrong.
SECOND FORENSIC AUDIT REPORT: EVIDENCE OF MALFEASANCE?
EVIDENCE OF MALFEASANCE?: A REVIEW OF THE FORENSIC
AUDIT REPORT INTO THE MUSKRAT FALLS PROJECT (PHASE II)
The second Forensic Audit Report prepared by the accounting firm of Grant Thornton has now been released to the public. It will constitute the major focus of Phase II, the “Construction Phase”, of the Commission of Inquiry into the Muskrat Falls Project (MFP).
This Report builds on the main conclusions of the first one released in September 2018, prior to the beginning of public hearings presided over by Judge Richard LeBlanc. It concluded that, at the time of sanction, a “combination of…potential misstatements may have resulted in the Interconnected Island Option (the Muskrat Falls project) no longer being considered the least cost option at the time of sanctioning.” In other words, had the Cumulative Present Worth (CPW) – the present value methodology used to compare the Isolated Island and the Interconnected Island options – been objectively assessed, the Muskrat Falls Project was probably not then, or ever, “least-cost”.
What had GT uncovered in order to come to that conclusion?
The second Forensic Audit Report prepared by the accounting firm of Grant Thornton has now been released to the public. It will constitute the major focus of Phase II, the “Construction Phase”, of the Commission of Inquiry into the Muskrat Falls Project (MFP).
This Report builds on the main conclusions of the first one released in September 2018, prior to the beginning of public hearings presided over by Judge Richard LeBlanc. It concluded that, at the time of sanction, a “combination of…potential misstatements may have resulted in the Interconnected Island Option (the Muskrat Falls project) no longer being considered the least cost option at the time of sanctioning.” In other words, had the Cumulative Present Worth (CPW) – the present value methodology used to compare the Isolated Island and the Interconnected Island options – been objectively assessed, the Muskrat Falls Project was probably not then, or ever, “least-cost”.
What had GT uncovered in order to come to that conclusion?
Thursday, 14 February 2019
EVERY TOWN SHOULD VOTE A BARD (suggests the Bard of Pynn's Brook)
POET
LAUREATES
(Poet
Laureate appointee in St. John’s)
Every
town should vote a bard
To
rhyme events in its backyard,
To
laud in lines the district scene
And
entertain the tourist keen:
Poet
Laureates sot in every bay
And
hamlet pitched along the way,
To
praise aloud the quaint and saint
And
Council deeds heroic paint.
Monday, 11 February 2019
POLL CLEAR AS MUD BUT LIKELY CANCELS SPRING ELECTION
Is anyone surprised that the latest MQO Poll places both the Liberals (44%) and the Tories (42%) in (possibly) a statistical tie? While neophyte PC Party leader Ches Crosbie has had an uninspiring start, which — for the Tories — aligns well with a non-performing Government, why would the public be in anything but a “show me” mood?
The Premier's approval numbers testify to the legitimacy of the questions. MQO gives Ball’s leadership a “relatively steady… mean score of 5.2 [on a 10 point scale] this quarter”. Crosbie, in spite of his inability to light any fires, oversees a jump in support of 7% as the NDP races to the status of non-entity.
MQO comments that declining support for the NDP reflects in the Tories' gain, but that is tantamount to suggesting change in the chemistry of oil and water. More likely, a pervasive leadership vacuum is adding room for fluctuation in the popularity of the two traditional Parties, it being left to both mainstream and social media to set the public agenda based on whatever passes as news.
Friday, 8 February 2019
MF COALITION TO HOLD PUBLIC MEETING FEBUARY 13
Notice of General Meeting of the Muskrat
Falls Concerned Citizens Coalition (MFCCC). Where? The Holiday Inn, 180 Portugal Cove Road, St. John’s (Salon
A&B). When? 7:00
p.m., Wednesday, February 13th. Also live stream via Facebook and Twitter.
David Vardy will make a Presentation. Ron
Penney, Des Sullivan and Coalition lawyer, Geoff Budden, will also discuss the Muskrat Falls project and bring
Coalition members, and the public, up to date on preparations for the Second
Phase of the Public Inquiry.
Monday, 4 February 2019
THE TAIL WAGGING THE DOG
Guest Post by Ron Penney
The Tail Wagging The Dog:
Reflections
on Phase 1 of the Muskrat Falls Inquiry
The
Muskrat Falls Inquiry has competed Phase 1 of the hearings, which focused on
the events leading up to the sanction of the project on December 17th, 2012.
We
hadn’t fully understood before the depths of hatred and contempt towards us
arising out of our early warnings about the dangers of the path that we were
on.
A
senior federal public servant told us in 2011 that the tolerance for dissent in
Newfoundland and Labrador was very low and that proved to be the case. So much
for the notion that “dissent is the highest form of patriotism”. We were
treated as unpatriotic because we opposed what has been turned out to be the
worst public policy decision ever made in Newfoundland and Labrador.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
