Unlike politicians, the latter rarely come in for criticism; nor should they unless they, too, have become ‘political’.Three people, historically, have constituted the most exclusive group of senior public servants: the Clerk of the Executive Council (also known as the Cabinet Secretary), the Deputy Minister of Finance and the Secretary to the Treasury Board. Now, there are only two; in 2005, Treasury Board was emasculated after it was rolled into the Dept. of Finance.
The Clerk of the Executive Council and the Deputy Minister of Finance are the two high priests of the public service. Their professionalism and leadership are always in demand. Those who occupy the positions are expected to be ‘macro’ thinkers, ‘fixers’ and ‘experts’ on public policy matters. They are the people, who whisper into the ears of other senior public servants, the Departmental Deputies, when the latter overstep sensibly constructed boundaries, especially those which are political. That is why the greatest currency of any senior advisor is an unblemished track record.Of course, there is never a guarantee that the Premier will ask for, or listen to, the counsel of her senior advisors. That is her prerogative. But, experience suggests the wiser ones prevail, more often than not.
The Dean of senior public servants, James G. Channing, served as Clerk of the Executive Council for 23 years, most of them under Premier Smallwood. Smallwood was an intense partisan. Yet, Channing, a consummate professional, never permitted himself a single professional lapse. Even after Moores came to power, in 1972, Channing was retained, such was his unblemished standing.
Against this background, you will understand my surprise when, on that December evening of Muskrat Falls sanction, the person witnessing the signature of the Cabinet document (which the Premier led us to believe was the Order giving official start to the Project) was none other than the Secretary to the Cabinet, himself. The Premier is not the person who signs an Order-in-Council. That is the prerogative of the Lieutenant Governor.
Of course, it was the right of the Premier to host the occasion. But, the Ceremony was about her and her policy initiative; it was prime time television. She did not invite the L-G to sign; the Opposition Parties were offered no role, so the function was entirely a partisan event.The Clerk ought to have advised the Premier of a different arrangement. He didn’t. In failing to so do, he committed an error in judgment, crossing an important and defined boundary.
As I write, public service lay-offs are in progress. That is unfortunate but, likely, necessary. The Clerk has presided over quite a bit of the empire building; while still small by the standards of most Departments, his own shop is now the largest in history. A staff of 20 or so (including secretarial staff) remained a constant, dating back to the Moores’ years of the 1970s; these days you will find more than three times that number in the Cabinet Secretariat, despite Intergovernmental Affairs and Aboriginal Affairs, for example, having been ‘spun-off’ to become separate Departments. If you want to know all about ‘bureaucratic bloat’, start with the Office of the Executive Council.Then, there is the esteemed Ministry of Finance.
Premier Danny Williams must have found the ‘old’ Treasury Board structure confining. The stern dictum of the bean counters has been silenced, possibly blunted by a more compliant, political Deputy of Finance.While, ultimately, the Budget mess is the responsibility of the politicians, it is proof that the last and the most recent Deputy Ministers have either not been engaged or they have been ignored.
Last September, the current Deputy, gave a Speech to the local Chapter of the Financial Management Institute. Her message was one of public support for the Muskrat Falls initiative. It wasn’t enough that she was unmindful of Muskrat as a political boondoggle; she had to display that she could be oblivious to the financial risk inherent in the undertaking.In a world in which senior advisors are expected to counsel common sense, she might have used her senior status to defeat Ed Martin and the empire builders, at Nalcor. Both she, and her predecessor, might have worked ‘tooth and nail’ to save the the Province from a long road of financial stress. They could have made their own sums available, even to the ‘naysayers’, possibly demonstrating that Nalcor might not have gone rogue. Likely they found such an initiative required excessive leadership risk and, anyway, ‘cheerleading’ has a motion that favours prevailing winds.
The Department of Finance is staffed by many excellent people possessed of knowledge and skills to independently assess the viability of Muskrat Falls. It is incredulous that they were not given a mandate to model the Project, to check Nalcor’s numbers, or to challenge that Agency’s financial analysis and conclusions. Nalcor reserved that role entirely for itself. Of course, Nalcor would have had to share its data base and agree to provide on-going updates. No Deputy Minister of Finance, I ever knew, would have been refused the information.What is the result? The Deputy Minister of Finance has no ability to run to her Minister or to the Premier, armed with an 'independent' analysis or the capacity to give her elected masters fair warning, if Ed Martin is blowing smoke.
Who would know that Nalcor’s Cabinet Submissions are routed through the Department of Natural Resources and not through Finance? Few would even care that that Deputy Minister does not get to play the role of Ed Martin’s courier! But, they might be shocked if they knew that the Deputy stood in a public place and supported the Muskrat Falls Project, using the third party information of Nalcor. Even today, a large part of the NL public believes that, even if the politicians are unwise, the most senior bureaucrats in the Government will have their back!Isn’t this where a wise Secretary to the Cabinet might whisper in the Finance Deputy’s ear and express puzzlement at her oversight? Evidently he, too, has checked the direction the political wind and chose to be quiet.
Little wonder I might suggest that the Premier look outside of Government for help.